Revisiting Analogical Reasoning in the Science Teaching: From the Reception to the Production Paradigm
Nikolaos Fotou, University of Lincoln (United Kingdom)
Abstract
Extensive research on science education has evidenced the effectiveness of analogies as a didactic device that, as argued in this conference paper, can facilitate the learning process of abstract concepts when the analogies are appropriately and effectively used [1, 2]. The paper summarises research on such a use of analogies but also switches attention to student self-generated analogies, as opposed to analogies generated by education researchers, teachers, or science text-book authors that the literature has largely focused on. It discusses the heuristic use and efficacy of student self-generated analogies as a tool in approaching and correctly understanding what is new and unknown. Such use of analogies derives from research [3, 4] with a wide age range of students, who, when asked to make predictions in situations never considered before and to then provide explanations about these predictions, self-generated analogies. As it was found in their explanations, it was by reasoning on the basis of these self-generated analogies that they approached the situations they were presented with and made a scientifically compatible prediction for. This heuristic use of student self-generated analogies can be used in revealing a scientifically compatible way of reasoning on the basis of student self-generated analogies which can be also productively used in the process of science teaching.
Keywords |
Self-generated analogies, Analogies in Science Teaching, Heuristic analogical reasoning |
References |
[1] Mozzer, N. B., & Justi, R. “Students' pre-and post-teaching analogical reasoning when they draw their analogies”, International Journal of Science Education, 34(3), 2012, 429-458. [2] Goswami, U. “Analogical reasoning: What develops? A review of research and theory”, Child Development, 1992, 62(1), 1-22. [3] Fotou, N., & Abrahams, I. “Students’ reasoning in making predictions about novel situations: the role of self-generated analogies”, Insights from Research in Science Teaching and Learning, N Papadouris et al. (Eds), Berlin, Springer, 2016, 123-138 [4] Fotou, N., & Abrahams, I. "From the known to the unknown: The role of spontaneous and self-generated analogies in students’ predictions about novel situations.", Research in Science & Technological Education, 2021, 1-15. |