Changes in Critical Thinking through Philosophical Strategies in Quantum Physics Education
Jesus Diego Tuero-Odonnell Zulaica, Universidad Pontificia Bolivariana (Colombia)
José Gilberto Castrejón Mendoza, Instituto Politécnico Nacional de México (Mexico)
Pamela Geraldine Olivo Montaño, Instituto Politécnico Nacional de México (Mexico)
Abstract
This paper explores the impact of philosophical didactics [1] on university engineering students encountering quantum phenomenology for the first time. This topic is particularly significant given the paradigm shift from classical to modern physics and the emergence of diverse interpretations [2]. To this end, a cross-sectional study with a qualitative approach was conducted, employing content analysis as its primary methodology. The study involved a group of twenty students and was supported by the theory of conceptual change [3] to foster the highest levels of critical thinking—analysis, synthesis, and evaluation—as outlined in Bloom's taxonomy [4]. A didactic sequence was developed, centered on Socratic debates that, while de-emphasizing mathematical methods, incorporated readings from popular science articles and expert video presentations. The evaluation instrument, designed by the authors and validated by subject matter experts, comprised twenty-one open-ended questions distributed across the ten sessions of the didactic sequence. The results obtained during the intervention conducted in 2024 indicate that the proposed strategy contributes to a gradual enhancement of analytical and synthetic skills. However, the findings are inconclusive with respect to improvements in evaluative skills
Keywords |
Critical Thinking, Bloom's Taxonomy, Philosophical Didactics, Teaching Quantum, Conceptual Change. |
REFERENCES |
[1] Sumiacher. (2016). La didáctica filosófica. In Á. A. Salas, Filolosofía con niños y adolescentes. México: UNAM.
[2] Okon, E. (2014). El problema de la medición en mecánica cuántica. Revista mexicana de física E., 60(2), 130-140.
[3] Pacaci, C., Ustun, U., & Ozdemir, O. F. (2024). Effectiveness of conceptual change strategies in science education: A meta‐analysis. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 61(6), 1263-1325.
[4] Inter-American Teacher Education Network, RIED. (2015). Caja de Herramientas Pensamiento Crítico. Washington, D.C., EEUU: Red Interamericana de Educación Docente. OEA. |