New Perspectives in Science Education

Edition 14

Accepted Abstracts

On the Role of Analogies beyond their Didactic Purpose

Nikolaos Fotou, Maynooth University (Ireland)

Ian Abrahams, University of Lincoln (United Kingdom)

Abstract

Research in science education has extensively defended the use of analogies as an effective instructional tool in facilitating students’ learning of science. The power of teaching science on the basis of analogies lies in that it allows students to form cognitive links between what they are learning and what they already know, harmoniously integrating, in this way, the new concepts with their existing ones. Whilst such prior research has added instructional value to the use of analogies in facilitating new concepts learning, what has not yet been studied directly is students’ self-generation of analogies and whether there is any connection between these analogies generated and misconceptions students may hold and are found to be persistent and widespread from early childhood to late adulthood.
We report in this paper on a cross-age study in which students from five different age groups were asked to make predictions across a range of novel situations and explain the reasons that led them to these predictions. Having reported elsewhere on the regular use of analogies students drew upon in order to make their predictions, we focus here on the analogies students self-generated per se and their connections to popular misconceptions. According to the findings, students’ self-generated analogies revealed not only the misconceptions they hold but also their origins. We suggest, therefore, that the use of analogies should be extended beyond the aim of facilitating the learning of new and unfamiliar concepts by comparing them with a concept or situation students are familiar with. We argue that they can serve as a diagnostic form of assessment revealing both the misconceptions students might hold as well as the prior knowledge upon which these are founded. 

Keywords: Analogies, Analogical Reasoning, Misconception, Diagnosing Misconceptions;

References

[1] Duit, R. “The role of analogies and metaphors in learning science”, Science Education, 1991, 75 (6), 649-672
[2] Eynseck, H. J. (2000). “Intelligence: A New Look”, New Jersey, Transaction Publishers, 2000
[3] Haglund, J. “Collaborative and self-generated analogies in science education”, Studies in Science Education, 2013, 49(1), 1-34
[4] Fotou, N., & Abrahams, I. “Doing with ideas: the role of talk in effective practical work in science”, School Science Review, 2015, 97(359), 25-30
[5] Fotou, N. “Students’ use of analogies in making predictions in novel situations”, Conference proceedings, New Perspectives in Science Education, 3rd Edition, Italy, Libreriauniversitaria.it, 2014, 336-341
[6] Fotou, N., & Abrahams, I. “Students’ reasoning in making predictions about novel situations: the role of self-generated analogies“, Insights from Research in Science Teaching and Learning, Switzerland, Springer International Publishing, 2016, 123-138
[7] Fotou, N., & Abrahams, I. “Students’ analogical reasoning in novel situations: theory-like misconceptions or p-prims?”, Physics Education, 2016, 51(4), 1-6
[8] Fotou, N. “Students’ predictions in novel situations and the role of self-generated analogies in their reasoning”, Unpublished Doctoral Thesis, University of Leeds, UK, 2014
[9] Fotou, N., & Abrahams, I. “Students’ reasoning in making predictions about novel situations: the role of self-generated analogies”, Insights from Research in Science Teaching and Learning, N Papadouris et al. (Eds), Berlin, Springer, 2016, 123-138
[10] Hynd, C. (1998). “Conceptual change in a high school physics class”, Perspectives on Conceptual Change: Multiple Ways to Understand Knowing and Learning in a Complex World, Guzzetti & C. Hynd (Eds.), Mahwah, NJ, Lawrence Erlbaum, 1998, 27-36
[11] Bar, V., Zinn, B., Goldmuntz, R., & Sneider, C. “Children’s Concepts about Weight and Free Fall”, Science Education, 1994, 78(2), 149-169
[12] Gunstone, R. F., & White, R. T. “Understanding of gravity”, Science Education, 1981, 65(3), 291-299
 

Back to the list

REGISTER NOW

Reserved area


Media Partners:

Click BrownWalker Press logo for the International Academic and Industry Conference Event Calendar announcing scientific, academic and industry gatherings, online events, call for papers and journal articles
Pixel - Via Luigi Lanzi 12 - 50134 Firenze (FI) - VAT IT 05118710481
    Copyright © 2024 - All rights reserved

Privacy Policy

Webmaster: Pinzani.it